Google For India 2023

Introduction

A zero-click cyber attack solely relies on software and hardware flaws, bypassing any human factor to infect a device and take control over its data. It is almost impossible to discover the attack and know that the device is hacked unless someone on your side is closely monitoring your network traffic data.

At Kaspersky, security analysts used their SIEM solution KUMA to monitor their corporate WiFi network traffic and discovered this mysterious attack. They took necessary actions to investigate it and even went a step further to dive right into the action and uncover the entire attack chain.

A few months ago, Kaspersky shared their findings about this attack on iOS devices. They shared how these zero-click vulnerabilities were being exploited by the attackers and called this attack ‘Operation Triangulation’.

A zero-click exploit in the network

Kaspersky detected a zero-click attack on the iPhones of their colleagues while monitoring their corporate WiFi network traffic. They managed to get detailed information on all the stages of the attack by simply identifying a pattern in the domain names flowing through their network. Although the attackers were quite experienced, their mistakes helped Kaspersky detect critical vulnerabilities in all iOS devices.

The name-pattern

These previously unsuspected domains had a similar name-style which consisted of two names and ended with ‘.com’, such as ‘backuprabbit.com’ and ‘cloudsponcer.com’. They were used in pairs, one for an exportation process and the other served as a command and control server. These domains showed high outbound traffic, they were registered with NameCheap and protected with Cloudflare.

The network pattern

Each time a connection to these suspicious domains was made, it was preceded by an iMessage connection which indicated these domains are being accessed by iOS devices. It was observed that the devices connected to these domains, downloaded attachments, performed a few requests to a first level domain which was an exploitation framework server, then made regular connections with the second level domain which was a command and control server controlled by the attackers.

Getting more information

To get more information about the attack all the infected devices were collected and backed up after carefully informing the device owners. Although the attackers had managed to clean their artefacts, the backed up data was used to perform digital forensic procedures and find traces of the attacks. This helped Kaspersky to figure out how the infection might be taking place.

The attacker’s mistakes

The attackers deleted all the attachment files and exploits but did not delete the modified SMS attachment folder. That folder had no files left inside it. The attackers removed evidence from other databases as well, like the ‘SMS.db’ database, however another database called ‘datausage.sqlite’ was not sanitised.

The ‘datausage.sqlite’ database is the most important database when it comes to iOS forensics as its contents can be used to track applications and network usage. Upon examination of this database, a process logged as ‘BackupAgent’ was found to be making network connections at the same time the device was making connections to the suspicious domains.

The indicator of compromise

‘BackupAgent’ stood out in this scenario because although it is a legitimate binary, it has been deprecated since iOS4 and it should not have been making any network connections. This identified the ‘BackupAgent’ process as the first solid indicator of compromise in Operation Triangulation. The indicator is termed as- ‘Data usage by process BackupAgent’, and was used to determine if any specific device was infected.

Taking it a step ahead

The team at Kaspersky successfully identified the indicator of compromise and determined which devices were infected, but as the attackers were experienced enough to delete their payloads, they decided to set a trap and perform a man-in-the-middle attack. When they did, the attackers were unable to detect it.

The man-in the-middle attack

Kaspersky prepared a server with ‘WireGuard’ and ‘mitmproxy’. They installed root certificates on devices that could be used as targets for the attackers and routed all the network traffic to that server. They also developed a ‘Telegram’ bot to notify them about new infections as they decrypted the network traffic.

Setting up a bot proved to be an effective way of real time monitoring while modifying all the network packets on-the-fly with ‘mitmproxy’, this gave them unlimited power! Their trap was successful in capturing a payload sent by the attackers and it was analysed in detail.

The name was in the payload

The payload was an HTML page with obfuscator javascript which performed various code checks and canvas footprinting. It rendered a yellow triangle and calculated its hash value. This is why the operation was named Operation Triangulation.

The team at Kaspersky started cracking various layers of asymmetric cryptography with regular expressions. They patched the stages one-by-one on the fly to move the logic from each stage to ‘mitmproxy’ and finally implemented a 400 line ‘mitmproxy’ add-on. This add-on decrypted all the validators, exploits, spyware and additional modules.

The mystery 

It is remarkable how Kaspersky detected the attack and identified multiple vulnerabilities, set up a trap to capture a payload and decrypted it completely. They shared all their findings with the device manufacturer and Apple responded by sending out a security patch update addressing four zero-day vulnerabilities. 

A zero-click vulnerability

Traditionally any spyware relies on the user to to click on a compromised link or file to initiate the infection. However a zero-click vulnerability is a specific flaw in the device software or hardware that the attacker can use to infect the device without the need for a click or tap from the user.

The vulnerabilities identified

1. Tricky Font Flaw (CVE-2023-41990): A clandestine method involving the manipulation of font rendering on iPhones, akin to a secret code deciphered by the attackers.Apple swiftly addressed this vulnerability in versions iOS 15.7.8 and iOS 16.3.

2. Kernel Trick (CVE-2023-32434): Exploiting a hidden language understood only by the iPhone's core, the attackers successfully compromised the kernel's integrity.Apple responded with fixes implemented in iOS 15.7.7, iOS 15.8, and iOS 16.5.1.

3. Web Sneakiness (CVE-2023-32435): Leveraging a clever ploy in the interpretation of web content by iPhones, the attackers manipulated the device's behaviour.Apple addressed this vulnerability in iOS 15.7.7 and iOS 16.5.1.

4. Kernel Key (CVE-2023-38606): The pinnacle of the operation, the attackers discovered a covert method to tamper with the iPhone's core, the kernel.Apple responded with a fix introduced in iOS 16.6, thwarting the intrusion into the most secure facets of the iPhone

Still, how these attackers were able to find this critical vulnerability in a device which stands out for it’s security features is still unknown.

CyberPeace Advisory

Zero-click attacks are a real threat, but you can defend yourself. Being aware of the risks and taking proactive steps can significantly reduce vulnerability. Regularly installing the latest updates for your operating system, apps, and firmware helps patch vulnerabilities before attackers can exploit them.

• Keep your software updated as they contain crucial security patches that plug vulnerabilities before attackers can exploit them.
• Use security software to actively scan for suspicious activity and malicious code, acting as a first line of defence against zero-click intrusions.
• Be cautious with unsolicited messages if the offer seems too good to be true or the link appears suspicious as it can contain malware that can infect your device.
• Disable automatic previews as it can potentially trigger malicious code hidden within the content.
• Be mindful of what you install and avoid unverified apps and pirated software, as they can be Trojan horses laden with malware.
• Stay informed about the latest threats and updates by following reliable news sources and security blogs to stay ahead of the curve, recognize potential zero-click scams and adjust your behaviour accordingly.

Check out our (advisory report)[add report link] to get in depth information.

Conclusion

Operation Triangulation stands as a testament to the continuous cat-and-mouse game between cybercriminals and tech giants. While the covert spy mission showcased the vulnerabilities present in earlier iPhone versions, Apple's prompt response underscores the commitment to user security. As the digital landscape evolves, vigilance, timely updates, and collaborative efforts remain essential in safeguarding against unforeseen cyber threats.

References:

1. Operation Triangulation: iOS devices targeted with previously unknown malware | Securelist, 1 June, 2023
2. Operation Triangulation: The last (hardware) mystery | Securelist, 27 December, 2023.
3. 37C3 - Operation Triangulation: What You Get When Attack iPhones of Researchers (youtube.com), 29 December,2023

Executive Summary:

A viral video has circulated on social media, wrongly showing lawbreakers surrendering to the Indian Army. However, the verification performed shows that the video is of a group surrendering to the Bangladesh Army and is not related to India. The claim that it is related to the Indian Army is false and misleading. 

Claims:

A viral video falsely claims that a group of lawbreakers is surrendering to the Indian Army, linking the footage to recent events in India.

Fact Check:

Upon receiving the viral posts, we analysed the keyframes of the video through Google Lens search. The search directed us to credible news sources in Bangladesh, which confirmed that the video was filmed during a surrender event involving criminals in Bangladesh, not India.

‍

We further verified the video by cross-referencing it with official military and news reports from India. None of the sources supported the claim that the video involved the Indian Army.  Instead, the video was linked to another similar Bangladesh Media covering the news.

‍

No evidence was found in any credible Indian news media outlets that covered the video. The viral video was clearly taken out of context and misrepresented to mislead viewers.

Conclusion:

The viral video claiming to show lawbreakers surrendering to the Indian Army is footage from Bangladesh. The CyberPeace Research Team confirms that the video is falsely attributed to India, misleading the claim.

• Claim: The video shows miscreants surrendering to the Indian Army.  
• Claimed on: Facebook, X, YouTube
• Fact Check: False & Misleading

‍

Introduction

Bumble’s launch of its ‘Opening Move’ feature has sparked a new narrative on safety and privacy within the digital dating sphere and has garnered mixed reactions from users. It was launched against the backdrop of women stating that the ‘message first’ policy of Bumble was proving to be tedious. Addressing the large-scale review, Bumble launched its ‘Opening Move’ feature, whereby users can either craft or select from pre-set questions which potential matches may choose to answer to start the conversation at first glance. These questions are a segue into meaningful and insightful conversation from the get-go and overstep the traditional effort to start engaging chats between matched users. This feature is an optional feature that users may enable and as such does not prevent a user from exercising the autonomy previously in place.

Innovative Approach to Conversation Starters

Many users consider this feature as innovative; not only does it act as a catalyst for fluid conversation but also cultivates insightful dialogue, fostering meaningful interactions that are devoid of the constraint of superficial small talk. The ‘Opening Moves’ feature may also be aligned with unique scientific research indicating that individuals form their initial attractions within 3-seconds of intimate interaction, thereby proving to be a catalyst to the decision-making process of an individual in the attraction time frame. 

Organizational Benefits and Data Insights

From an organisational standpoint, the feature is a unique solution towards localisation challenges faced by apps; the option of writing a personalised ‘Opening Move’ implies setting prompts that are culturally relevant and appropriate in a specific area. Moreover, it is anticipated that Bumble may enhance and improve user experience within the platform through data analysis. Data from responses to an ‘Opening Move’ may provide valuable insights into user preferences and patterns by analysing which pre-set prompts garner more responses over others and how often is a user-written ‘Opening Move’ successful in obtaining a response in comparison with Bumble’s pre-set prompts. A quick glance at Bumble’s privacy policy[1] shows that data storing and transferring of chats between users are not shared with third parties, further safeguarding personal privacy. However,  Bumble does use the chat data for its own internal purposes after removing personally identifiable information from chats. The manner of such review and removal of data has not been specified, which may raise challenges depending upon whether the reviewer is a human or an algorithm.

However, some users perceive the feature as counterproductive to the company’s principle of ‘women make the first move’. While Bumble aims to market the feature as a neutral ground for matched users based on the exercise of choice, users see it as a step back into the heteronormative gender expectations that most dating apps conform to, putting the onus of the ‘first move’ on men. Many male users have complained that the feature acts as a catalyst for men to opt out of the dating app and would most likely refrain from interacting with profiles enabled with the ‘Opening Move’ feature, since the pressure to answer in a creative manner is disproportionate with the likelihood their response actually being entertained.[2] Coupled with the female users terming the original protocol as ‘too much effort’, the preset questions of the ‘Opening Move’ feature may actively invite users to categorise potential matches according to arbitrary questions that undermine real-life experiences, perspectives and backgrounds of each individual.[3]

Additionally, complications are likely to arise when a notorious user sets a question that indirectly gleans personal or sensitive, identifiable information. The individual responding may be bullied or be subjected to hateful slurs when they respond to such carefully crafted conversation prompts.

Safety and Privacy Concerns

On the corollary, the appearance of choice may translate into more challenges for women on the platform. The feature may spark an increase in the number of unsolicited, undesirable messages and images from a potential match. The most vulnerable groups at present remain individuals who identify as females and other sexual minorities.[4] At present, there appears to be no mechanism in place to proactively monitor the content of responses, relying instead on user reporting. This approach may prove to be impractical given the potential volume of objectionable messages, necessitating a more efficient solution to address this issue. It is to be noted that in spite of a user reporting, the current redressal systems of online platforms remain lax, largely inadequate and demonstrate ineffectiveness in addressing user concerns or grievances. This lack of proactiveness is violative of the right to redressal provided under the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. It is thought that the feature may actually take away user autonomy that Bumble originally aimed to grant since Individuals who identify as introverted, shy, soft-spoken, or non-assertive may refrain from reporting harassing messages altogether, potentially due to discomfort or reluctance to engage in confrontation. Resultantly, it is anticipated that there would be a sharp uptake in cases pertaining to cyberbullying, harassment and hate speech (especially vulgar communications) towards both the user and the potential match. 

From an Indian legal perspective, dating apps have to adhere to the Information Technology Act, 2000 [5], the Information Technology (Intermediary and Digital Media Ethics) Rules 2021 [6] and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, that regulates a person’s digital privacy and set standards on the kind of content an intermediary may host. An obligation is cast upon an intermediary to uprise its users on what content is not allowed on its platform in addition to mandating intimation of the user’s digital rights. The lack of automated checks, as mentioned above, is likely to make Bumble non-compliant with the ethical guidelines. 

The optional nature of the ‘Opening Move’ grants users some autonomy. However, some technical updates may enhance the user experience of this feature. Technologies like AI are an effective aid in behavioural and predictive analysis. An upgraded ‘matching’ algorithm can analyse the number of un-matches a profile receives, thereby identifying and flagging a profile having multiple lapsed matches. Additionally, the design interface of the application bearing a filter option to filter out flagged profiles would enable a user to be cautious while navigating through the matches. Another possible method of weeding out notorious profiles is by deploying a peer-review system of profiles whereby a user has a singular check-box that enables them to flag a profile. Such a checkbox would ideally be devoid of any option for writing personal comments and would bear a check box stating whether the profile is most or least likely to bully/harass. This would ensure that a binary, precise response is recorded and any coloured remarks are avoided. [7]

Governance and Monitoring Mechanisms

From a governance point of view, a monitoring mechanism on the manner of crafting questions is critical. Systems should be designed to detect certain words/sentences and a specific manner of framing sentences to disallow questions contrary to the national legal framework. An onscreen notification having instructions on generally acceptable manner of conversations as a reminder to users to maintain cyber hygiene while conversing is also proposed as a mandated requirement for platforms. The notification/notice may also include guidelines on what information is safe to share in order to safeguard user privacy. Lastly, a revised privacy policy should establish the legal basis for processing responses to ‘Opening Moves’, thereby bringing it in compliance with national legislations such as the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023.

Conclusion

Bumble's 'Opening Move' feature marks the company’s ‘statement’ step to address user concerns regarding initiating conversations on the platform. While it has been praised for fostering more meaningful interactions, it also raises not only ethical concerns but also concerns over user safety. While the 'Opening Move' feature can potentially enhance user experience, its success is largely dependent on Bumble's ability to effectively navigate the complex issues associated with this feature. A more robust monitoring mechanism that utilises newer technology is critical to address user concerns and to ensure compliance with national laws on data privacy.

Endnotes:

• [1] Bumble’s privacy policy https://bumble.com/en-us/privacy  
• [2] Discussion thread, r/bumble, Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/Bumble/comments/1cgrs0d/women_on_bumble_no_longer_have_to_make_the_first/?share_id=idm6DK7e0lgkD7ZQ2TiTq&utm_content=2&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1&rdt=65068 
• [3] Mcrea-Hedley, Olivia, “Love on the Apps: When did Dating Become so Political?”, 8 February 2024 https://www.service95.com/the-politics-of-dating-apps/ 
• [4] Gewirtz-Meydan, A., Volman-Pampanel, D., Opuda, E., & Tarshish, N. (2024). ‘Dating Apps: A New Emerging Platform for Sexual Harassment? A Scoping Review. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 25(1), 752-763. https://doi.org/10.1177/15248380231162969 
• [5]  Information Technology Act, 2000 https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/13116/1/it_act_2000_updated.pdf 
• [6]  Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics) Rules 2021 https://www.meity.gov.in/writereaddata/files/Information%20Technology%20%28Intermediary%20Guidelines%20and%20Digital%20Media%20Ethics%20Code%29%20Rules%2C%202021%20%28updated%2006.04.2023%29-.pdf 
• [7]  Date Confidently: Engaging Features in a Dating App (Use Cases), Consaguous, 10 July 2023 https://www.consagous.co/blog/date-confidently-engaging-features-in-a-dating-app-use-cases  

‍